Cover Story

Rice Tarrification:  Good or Bad for the Country?

How should government manage its rice imports? Can we ever be rice sufficient? Resurgent contributor Fermin D. Adriano explains the economics of this enduring but controversial "political crop."

Fermin D. Adriano
  • 03/07/2017
  • eJztfWl36riy6Pvca/EfICOEyTYzGZkhIQmZSMhEDDiBhACxYXfv++H99ifJkzzIloF9b7+7zupz shNbrpJKpZpUJW0HWjfRwmDaE6KJGOP3/bW9XRIFfj4V83702N8YjxfSXISPgtchP5uOMbBVoZHt Ki3bgiiNppM8eie/rcLvgyVeHIf8wRB8cjuajwXwrC30wSf+m29enPsve5/gT84f40chDTUAVebn oC0b57g4x7BpP5cHP1rnqAk/+cVL0ui/YIN0IpuAD4vTxWQwmnwUp//k/WmW82czrD/DZPy5NAvf 10fXgmRuFGNzbFJpmZb/UJqXp/3FtzCZt8RpX5Ck0nQ8FaW8v/Sbn/jP+Q/whvd3hPF4+re/OOb7 X+CbQiPVrY7GAhj4Nz/3A+gMespy3eJiNB5cLL57AqBJOsuh54kugnonAXAAMvwdPc90G9/g0Y0w n4OuAqSInNe1It4X8BT9F3y6Fj5GaHIA0V5CKmRxOgPk/ZKchwmb3grfszEgNqJJhmFiKX80if7B /1Abg/GhhlxKAZROpEEjlknk5L9ZNpfSmutUFH6NhL/z/ovpRFBIVRDnN/IUJgEG+afy6noxFsS7 yWgOu4+e5WRanU8Hwhh8oYOojnlEIvQfq/9UWtzy4ocwBzM/HS/miEGzGhYwH03+twCnlVWQXM6E ye20jbqaTIPBMEkWjI4Dv6QYf5pj/Vwa4chkwfwyGlpW/6kAh5AgHBVDBs5hC0zrpTj6GE3yiVzS H83k0sqM18TRQJ/wDOBe+QcaSyyL/T+n/l/pMiDAfC5M1DEAZiudY6zDxM5vIOrKZFCafsO5kNBq AUwzAfw0nn4ob/U/0DsAYjFTxoIedMHUtcTRBAL2/XUhv8t2W+MFeFkTp4tZY/I+9f0VlEWGvMbB /A6UFQ6EAGJr/63I9wGMkCoHQBuw9mchF4BgnKLgl9+Cb9Gf4N93+C/N92XhHaxLHYD8tDL5JYyn Mwyw9oSfDPz3vDijAd4a8xNe9KMXGuzm6Bd4wwOS6dD1Z1RgAevMAJHQR6iNCYVDA+wVFSp+PgSS TJgMJA26/Kep8/JDGpA3v7970/FI+tYA4k+03yl7NxfEyeVE7qa4kIb+2+l0rBNCbqC80idZnMvf /GuQaI3tEICX/17gJX48Hn2I/Gw46tvBt3mvISJ8S8VFfUR1O4zGVxoy6xf/JjwqE1UGI2gE2S9r xzY3f/Pz/hCIl57IiyPBZS3C6X0fTQagozeL0VzQ52v6PYPmkP9myM/gY9iyirXU4aa6QEHgCiAa dVUNy3yTk99By2D+eywATRU/m0z/nqC//HkwmicgxvnFeP4S8scv+G/BHwFtbkbAghG0Roz/Ev7Q dTPrf+Dhk2vwI5ZJMUCNM7E0UL7ZBPqF4TgOalRgZiaVzx4K8ANW/es3/OsU/PYJnv0NrAH/uf/p hfEPfOAlAItwDEBXZHG/7/vLHwc9hb+gYQFSYINyp06LHwMVLsjDaPXo+202BxEFHv4LUs5sJ7b6 4P9FvTcaTm+T1ARADRNjHbLcZEmeYBn5pawvIKj/oz4HwMxPSRiUTqv2KHAuAEdsd+PqA8g38M9R H5KHF3/LDxh/vAFe4soUWmrd69HHcA6VvtAeSaPeaDya/76Z83B1RZy+q46nU3GJ75rCuzO6aAqY 0PFrgR+3pmDg8KFNrwVgK4I/UC/a/GQkDQGF0AcKoODTuTAYLb79usUMVxowxfvA8r6ZA6J+APnR YFm/RjlkKfoVMxTIDmDrS8LcD1enAjX+cN68AN8TiLzvD/7zPZ6ABlEAQxz1FnNBUj8tiCKvtPvv AbMmLFi7/hA4f6IwUVpxyhyrr+GP+e+ZSqzgzkTq/uJFaR8QXqU43vYXP15ojeELidBwos+A0hvJ +Of/96SaAG+Shkrjaf9LGFCRSW26TsZdfoC9EQpXsDSDBDwDlqK87CgGijdfJ1OsThTWmSh0pBjx vbFAtTJoZvp/nBGgUOgvpPn0+w+KhX/FKL2Jvvwv+lHCtp44/Y+yaF7iodUKLRGwDuk59b9j3YAO /dv68+8g0Lcw5wdgxtbQmdzKndkcKCYY1RLAWqumJjQX/cHiWBAG0MBsY8BVQxTGkQuiwBeQFWmn DcxSAgYVelNeHPhZq+WIqRtWxd8qXCuPsiyTUILK2YTVnEVRYTl8aupleSTNxvzvc178Ut5ocW4Y 9NYBAQv4dnotw1Bs5Kk0gv1Hrznlay1knkt7+JrVR1acTsHIGpJKC8U5urDjD7UNIqragVQqkVIG B5wXP6/StA+j4MClEzUbJcUluSy5Kefv6bPq2vZDFDQGde2DF8B6fxmVOsiLUJnS/zUBhtd0MQdd QFEOp7Yj4JsA5wd0QEDmkUr3lMbTsA/ngjT0X/PSXBBH/4W8XsyrUT5JMIZPLhfzGeiCy0euhMGp yGENgfM9kWY8kAH936DRaOCHe1gqCbO5LOvg/hV1amcBb/qzySTr6vFpfmNxOge2A+7qsRhtGf+7 5r71x6MZGAnUTf+AafsA45ZsPmFlP0/8JfhvhX/mKFTFy56p2jqpDd3qLjb5yccC7ga0pjNtui2y JJFWZ2fGDywM9M1LX+aeSbPp3NyOH48kfL5RpwazUUx5qPYTTJ+oy8tCw19YzKcaMwhWnsz5Z/wM kEwafS/GPMYhLJE7tAbuc3fT58easIS7nBpQlZbyPuiNbd/YNDan/GQ+8gMy8CodUipda+Npjx9f C7PFWNL7b9QNt9OZSTVgL1EkBH9N4quZyi7TX4I4g9EZtTMZfTEZvhAR5aO/5N1i0E1+0hdMcwYp rIQeoIK5WvCQA/1N4Zcw9rxa9KiOdblkcikAJcGm6ddcSRiPK//MdZWbTQNlhLpD1RPbCA0xIqUr x8ZkIPxzI/Snk4HHj6ojUZprS0VT0Kav4LgwpktwmXTGKU5Ww8ShU2MUlsLEHJfmNBliR2QcbibD UpJWtnRsKIuLddtxXGs6LJnKZkg9Q6PAu5ZNJig5R+c/C+twKeJ01OEW6nRSF+DXmip0mrzSdKEB dp0QfNQkoJCmVb4vFCYfmsgidxiBvZzxfV1XkEEjmphh0y9pGCVV7TPXjiFcpo5lia3h7j5gIWB7 zjHB5DLq93dJ0DpChg0Japh/x0A0tmYcYKKmBqAkUQ3MsPFoIviluTj90jxjxqX1HJgB+Pxkcp5E LtAyhkg0m4SJRJhr81VoVBfjsar8lIwj8NZ1XiE1jdNK30FNmpv6Z9SCsr6wc6DM8GBWCyZwHMSb vvA4Qqtb3V20RqyMcYwbYVzn54B2zSkwK6AfIuH+Bqk1QCuIjbKhLf7+FnrnELX2DlClPxUHwsCm X/74xXRufP+fDZZ1bLA4+/KqNdoE9pTqbDbKKzn6NjO5gt+fSSYysZQ/nUomYpnUSn5/KpeE6WhR LpPijLAoXf9oKgHT2bhkJsZ5+Px/xvdncV9kMtVNa/9ognw42EXBmfUwnuP8wOlx4jNcYaDGJegs lhRn8drgLOJWPWorO1JxJfmzaDDnDX643LwJdQrMWYF5WMjFtDjiBodf/qom8oMRXDTwKzkCYP7K nQ6sv9K6oSaE3PpS0YI3Bp2JE0Fu50QFK1QH+hoHLzenGL2R0vJnFKT+T5TpXx1lolCzMv64vuER n318f8V6UGNM399jIuY+UDSfT2f0jcdAI5lEt6UxGlaPFyW3hiKWx+LWdsZ/CKPJ+1Rtp8l0m7YD 4R2u4L9Hg/lQFRVWTWb57HPam8O8dg+fyBt576Ox2SqxtBQm0MAaOFG6Lw5iUO6P+VnsF21DdYAp G8Sw3UzRbQ79g80AwWbDqfhfqrTjSA2Biwoz5t1AjsWYpsJ6MKvepXF/OgHN5zDoJ9FzYw8Z6+oy I7ZH6fMm7qVorS8Misb4oqNobug5S2IabaALSQBGJLIJnVbV+2QeG4xn4vt0MndcfVIM2hRAGUou S0+KAX0JPcQJaGsJveJN/5nFRNFWr9s1/bA0JTRUGANzSe2opTeUPV3npjCIimKoui6wwy4ORMm0 blm7mUXtVC9acqJ7/zumBk/7378d14TecjofCqLTHM1ERQ45sRNoNJDNV82+thegoCEuOLNJjtRs iMepgsA4BjJ34O/99pdF4HiILuITAJjY+D0GIpg7Q25l6IstQWErtG1DJ96BMjD1z1ZufYPPXUW1 +BFzHoHSSBX6LENsJsGtBA2aa8NfTt1HrWbj/m8HvpEb9SeSI21BoznwtB1XExJoEkwidWuEpJ6r kSFq0tmu37IkNM6ObSNp0dMD5fYScIxtQRCEZG8EDTbnNhPhg8c8cqJcnsxRLpxTozELxTevB/jt dSUQ3kN+IIiC5CS+ZrLwwkRXxs6YAHKzZ/ZxbOUwsCScRfp01p+6tZCcKIBaDBaeAjGm712WtizS F5M+nbBAzfnJRNux1J1QSzNXUQ1EP8a3QVQt52+Wys5dQApjilminD1oYI8JeBALy8J3gj4djwXk lxhdZwsGaT5W9Qyy/TTN5UJB+J3yATY1NB/NBpBa4wl9v2YDevDybOmfsFmSNhzBkjjcwnRrqpuX qUzGuSluXGYZ+1WsNTaYlg56dYrvYDhoVnM7C22hqhwI0uhjgrsFdvwHW8ouASxXcbKUtJZTF+dK a8hLvdH8m3eSPbCt3Mhife5rqRAw5lZQv/FjEfH/TfkfeKAkpcenW6N/hDHA/C707YD/8UwRm3jH vzxxhE3DWGUBZmUUjB6FJcJqH1dkSM1urR6P1sScd2HsEAwE2vWIIYY67XEpbRyQLZ824zbtdjJc X+rjcci5mfQ1mvXAalGZw14fI4CAIcFi/nCTMSIwAkVJgF0UXZCrfVQH7sHjUD+h6RHUyfq+llGA nU57sGgQF19/OlHppl17sEhf8LB8WzavCPC09fGuB67+GxKYUPxdZkP8sAoXCfqfTKf/ZDr9J9Pp P5lO/8l0+k+m0/+OTCeVGjf8L+EcOMMj4BwUTHYKbaYPbpCMJl9jaR4D/zCy/eNgvOBtlag9ZWus qsbO+DI0FfkZbqy5ggbtMfBMLG3rZuOfDISJhLk+qaTbB++i8LOALqNmYrl9wWMCxG0EI8m4p+AC eTzvj0XWW3POW/OEt+ZJdRkpp2OhI7pC9qY7/jUW+nFvDL1DLLDnTFTWAy+zJl52ZlAW52W7UImh qSdeZq28nHFhNNYrL7MWXnZHQc/LrCdeZr3xMuuNl1lvvMySeFk5ac6VnVkv7Mx6Y2fOAztzJnZ2 5lEOZ2e7bRRDU0/szFnZ2U1uchZ2dpk1zsLOrh/QczPniZs5b9zMeeNmzhs3cyRuls9LdGVmzgsz c96YOeGBmRMmZnbm0ATOzEm3pp6YOWFmZjZmG/rHv/AomhMWXnbj/oQHZk54YuaEN2ZOeGPmhDdm TpCYuSjnJ7mwZ8ILLyfMvOzARn3Ms1WjeI3Jlx8ehYQH8FzTtp3DizB43CpXu3LOIg== 6Ix8JCrcXsH29OzEvPql0rox6Y8XEnJQxyPH5AH1Q7SFWUIrkPY7d9fOCSFhjF4RO2yg2G6Re4gF ErCzsPc1kf9d0tOzlPigsy6jTWDlOELHNczl6d8T+UALdMhnoTfVUhbss7nsP3ZKnTV3nC6N1olk CocRaJb28OXZSItAOtMKfbg0sUxfWwabdPz6fDqZOqC2Ezb4p/2hOP0W7Adta1qpH8uhoCr4uiDO /56KX019u9s+K9CK1mHQ3nBfu2VcEr+8dUwdUj9T9zoLfXHa4+fy8b+hJWQtkHwDlIPbAKp8Pnof 6UkRnlNX1M7p+wdySQMmwr3RouiWiOo0gxjf0FASO3wcbh2Dzpf4mbyBPNLkerCkJMisJR9F7YJc TjXSNgRJ+eNq+1tx9A2Lke4Ft2R6A4Zb51x6Q1ucf51lm7xOC46hBW2C1Z0q6n4YOcBxFd8sepB7 ppP5NRTSDhajmY5OuR4mnr7FcisovroWPmgRtOQEI9gcK7h0FdNFvZSBQPkkbKsmaNN0BAjshl7M QClN4Kmu3r5QDgr9jS2S4O0QLEY/PIF7PhT8Sk6UX1LOGff/PRQmfon/BWHyE/y+AD80o/y8BB8r h9uWq1qRTcx/JyGQ4KcR2O/pwj8Dto8fKHVBXvYItQzugx9NYI0bhijiB8i0TyeApP75FILoC/4R Kojj/WP+Nyz+4WczYNLJBoO06A9h9xqTMkpG0sHI2CZgFSxA76bvOvqR5F9MvuDBtDE6igLQfXE0 c8lbV1sDVp7NBMp0M4LSoDB3QacAVZVNI8zEJXTNZSOESznZS9DKg1cHYJupTl27mfOTAS96JAE2 IKNio7WZKRWT0WSl/MhkuuEGoyPl0Hcm0jna03CC+LlwO1x89yb8aOxYGGNUdJhZ5qJZAJENGVyO AhoY6PdCD24i6v4qeCGbICVNJ5v7+S8srLfxn/9n6uxVTrtp16BelTXs3CZpCzRAUhf1ZMZbPEkF AOytUWzony/m0zNBnJg4A2bjiEJ/JFmFDXhV+e4BUwV5ZiZSw5cTsJL1vib1N+i0aKOS1fqhXlNi ++of5Rx7KzI4Ogzivs0UYod0m86HhiwsHxwNUagvfX8h3sYfQdYo3JQajWyqLEA5hSCHj1JvmfBx uxdn4uHzaPh4OE/A37jkwVU+ob240n5DL/YTx7fzYvk9V/uqb14f8uV3pnOkveXCh9fpYSCUqB8G ovHda4AmED76OgiELh5zgchwBN69vccC4UX+JhA5fygHosw5x8QPO0GEPxUoha6SEiedg96Vv5LH l29HiWI2kU0/pr8fD6Jv1WnmPsEM9LdMvSuUABpRPDrsFSKzi9OTs5x0lK0f3Meq08dkuyI+PzLl x2rntnpYOOyze4XMREGT2PI2OEg0eXyimAxE2q+NQDQbzQbC/dgNHFcWPqsEIt1BKhAafY0DoXlx BAcXwgeXjFzD34qgJ88FNJCjXH3rUx8SQINGJQVedsvc7tFG2dQqFpeyNe54s/4K/qyNmcFOp6wO pCmJ4r7UFp/H2TMmnryR6aqTCny5/ZA4uQoGIZrBDouIcalPnvhS2juJJZrZRfioFtjRJwNhTU6v byYkrK/iS3d4Y8KqjSZbO3xL/ezNGFusr+nHFglrfXPciz/aYz0IPEmb7U4LorEd7tXh7lG+9HRq hzW8308eELCmNzfbjxcpE1aEBiFOdh6ZajF9aYt1o/qZ3Zok9lt2WJnqe79OxLrDJTsVeXnaDDfZ GTC1mtixH2v1544r3fbgvCanlnnd/c4rWFu7uwirjEaZ2oTYjg8RVsCZvYpxap/El3K7BbGGrAyV fEnOY3dRe6yz+ilAY0KsY01fMPubJKx98TXLPthjvajsbf6kF+c6VoBGRyxtzopVEtb6MTdhH+2x JkOd8P747sIW60aVh5dHmRDjU3t2VSRgTW9up7KpYwLWTpepTm9vdaxwNBji2tbhTlMY3tlirV1l 28Sx7kQDMWVeK89fVcPi2YD3IUi7JxEJIt6zDLfe/VaXbGZmxtpsXLwoWDvRoGmsmVQs9qhjhZyG D/exyDS/rzL2WBsbi2yz08/aYr0cC3UiVoDmLPYzi9gPN/kUZm6aPwt7rGeJ12a1ehywxXrbGDV0 rHBujIhvztO3bySsZabNvObssTajm7eD7t6+HVYobNqvhxJxuO2g0J2RsJ4z99HjIgFrJXx/khVL CCtAYx7uY+T2lYj1c+O2WSRgfU4zL/xb2A4r5LSNi7vRV377ImJL5NfXhy4R61Q4Dn6QsJ4zb5Vm GWFFnGZetXfsxsP8qmGHVRQvopsK1l4iZFo84dxeJSFj5TfmNR0rMjkOAnlxkSgxEHHEgvXyMPjz Wnk4AVgPRbPmyU87EQXrV27PhHX7/WnjHWEFaLhih20YZcU1U7l4qkGsUatcvIiqmqc0N1O4UvmM yViPg5WIjhVK6LiUGu4OwoqESmzlS2dGuSiED7MXTxBr3Io1vb1x2KnXAdbTgAlrgCteDhFWNDf5 q5hpuJ/Tw8qXjPX4rtk0qndA5s/hFOk7pv7WKuFvufl3gMtPeqa3upLmFjuBxOB7Zv95MgQWz1FK IL0VAUecjwhvZZOjcnBZkRtYNPXjIdM8SXDorVXePx4zzevjJOltgWkOztLoLUBj06DEnAfus6TP K8xlv3FNettlbkpfc9NbzLJ5ijA37c0A4fOnGHN7ch4kvU0xd4GfmP3bgwC83VBcBDJKA6vUqjPt u8Ch/Na44uDbU6b9ET0mvW0y91u5gkY0a4ML5j5dKZE+bzGPm5kX0ttP5uXhcc/0FiPac4Z5+XyP ED5/zjGvd/sJ0tsTppvu5ghvu/DiTTa2d5YiNOCDbO6NOye87W2yxZ3XKuntDXt2tXFKJlp/yl58 cSPC54MQ2/k827F/m3qd3O4fzB+JROOkVmA3dIpsrSDwdIJ1w+qWCoFY/eRIfmuWgtx8HDhInn7a v02GnqGwOeA+rkgNXsIH+9/X2NtSdO9acQqBdDuaBQe34eJUupAl2dHhbBtz3irPQlEVnSb/DYlE UTxmt0/i891S9fY400EOaPmxchADz5hqqRjrl0rF+FkYfHYzUz572x7D7iRkhBjqzcSubKqffsv+ 0N1s/KQL0fh5drIL/MyHBfKHgKh9P9Ac28346LAXAktxowKcoXzLILrFDW73sBVVnaHLc6MtABGr WFPDve2DwNQea7LzQMa6UR3ETVihWtMQM9Xb4hUBKzCaL0fnPAnrmwPWWjRntAUGOzubOlZRyocl DWvCgDVbTz4Mm/sq1trYQOGNII41ebMF0OiIxcUbGyNiRTxHwAo8TuBXPNtjTXaeZDcKR2wg8jdH xIpcCyJW6FcMdKxwNAbEAhlr9uLqgYwVGilECgM00E7pkoZ7ZZnazXxEwY9+U9g979wOCRul6T4V yORzk65dqCW3g3JD9giaaWM8ybCIqwvgzu8+lZRVwF8XkWEoyxmVuPraP2Ejd2xE+/Gkzo1iaCjx pBm+sN7CEwjjGovdHbV2prCD0NK/OcFlFMR/mtreRj/glN6bvDUFw6XWozL0LquolYrw9FgJTdXu WuDPnW3lB/9Q1l0AU1APNH4qs5UXqabEbJQxY50+qmwrPyLnU5lAskegCmd9DIAPSwYa4qQvxodC eRsyNPgXcOYx03DultaE0KdIJSL/UEjKYqFEzMWVCb+gIDz6oYwQue62I2wF9BHK2tMySO3HNe4j 2cwhsL/P3eawu0BulNJ92WUyxUtl1tJmetk5RNFBeZD7YY/0InPEfsQESg+mOLG9Pc/XOjNn/tKZ S2FoMn8x7+xGh4L6zqRHtgCgvhu3Uq+gfcaO9OrcuNPLKIViU4sU6kRmBgza+AF4iMbDjFTgQGoY DK3TBikU2kG8SVyencic2COlJ0DUox8K+VCo1oZ8lee2eXnictx+ecqekc3gjtmzJsXg5LnBx2cY XHTTeXDyD6EV2zmahQ5m9mSutb6hcUvQT/q4duRx2fP8a4URpK975yGh0VinzMRBSGdonUjYs3vt bMdkyBs4DcxWOb4O2nTJihuORpjfxRUO0hhadoBsofUkIjQiKFxJGxcgO7MswB73QzFqu9Vn9AhA j6owYtVwmNDuYhcYgecRTTzZ7u2BxnyVe1kU0TZVQgneE2YV/lC6L0e/rQwCRmiUhwZQkWIQ9Ul2 PLC+hYl9Y95LsSfCMC+v7KwzfYYVohmnJfljmZavrOis9JylkEGtgXE9SCRNZWtNGk1JfYZrJhEr L0+jpqKe5EGN5bd26xRGFWZysHZbtJBeuYAbvQ57Qec+IYcddIsrPuZO7bulmXkkW8/Yp00n7anP IIUyAST92nK0NjbdPAJ8Gl1sPQ9ziGQa371bDzRG+BTadqDkufEMzahg3DuGi04LtPfdn4f1Ec3F 4PMyzPd88HF9RDNJN89EUyJhasxmfvRj8m654sMrUR6ZLWfdbFZEp7G/H3Wj8neyde11dh3u7tSd ZRpufdsaEGBIXxvrWp51uAdz5sWdDhFm8wMGUxJb+2fNlQjk7hnKuRzOBOrGqOMNDqMhSggPU9W1 9Wr0nqiOh3Nn3OSBa0/QFt5Dl1uZLEQBgHoiM7TJf8z/2Ous+ZHkoP7snEe0Naq6USg8jthIyx6D 3dLj4KBHnw0gD/gKPQZD+MNo2bxIk4AXSUJaKJ8Nky1icgpdu2Xo03yTVhSY0nksa6+xHlEgK4LP Br0ocB7hPLxrN0I4Gs+Ed7MezJybnOqKwMi8x8HynN0rflbXMEJpyGFWJ12AlOC6A4+o9vxD5Agl CElPL8fFbkcvBAXFoa308rjYDfQyrvSYqtYMi/371LjYCW6caywqsZXf2KAKpjgGHb5PHVxBayAX z4S0shsrRxTcAgbugVykpPPs7ooRle/TxHH79pw4OCRsXGMhia3cD7NKIESRAqcATXu68pDMWhaP 3DrH9QxTdbowCnjqIJFB30DapLyFSwixnVNTbMeBoTftQxJGM/s435qbzOzE8d12wER/LRPS0dK2 zsPszFOMTRc2RtY6vmOdw4ZmK5mkF8+QXlS1p1NElMJKnp0Z9eKS6+b47jC0CrvLDD07MytEyjA2 zu75q4BREWJD0kdDM6Tt5JKiAOe0M4sGXEIUAMKYNB/sk5qoTFB+BDMXEsio+Vz0EkKjWro2ym8X oN7cxTZ1wW8l8Cz47T5qbPWRww8PN0vubuDjqrW+8d0oGg3oEN6C0LQorfO6oYjSAmjOq5BOQsPF w64axoczFwqaoBB2Ct0B7Xnqjv0OOwIUXsu4cMtmJUBRiu4oCTDOuhBBi62gVjWiqRZxKGR1Ox9u V96ewIQNgGbyzJZWP7Bjhl0jyp1CIjUHOxzNTpYa5TD58XbSDbg2qZBJuoFneQrzbhNtrLiYFw93 K0s3NDfA4PRk3ztJNwDKRropSRZe96AANE/SjWBAwYB2YmUpAPf199YhBawJFWROcw== BUQjTpyhyPnQ+zSSxL07caLvjxz2afhQ5SVLJMxm0sJOe0rKDiT8EdcNF2OUQ1Z56pKBTtGeOWcM PKOZDKqMrhJ41yBuZFNabA9tXeJq2nPpPWEAzV3i6rFON6Hbpk2osJM4uhSodWbOTjeFmY1mzpgw RRY2roCIhj8Rikl7aoBWzaqQoWhut/NGvisg2pwmLTOFuB4RtOWC3LpyxAPEu0AX18Jm/chvNCl8 HhffW3YKH+7XYf0/k/MgdFOdWj8CaI7Wv51yJEVuIbQlrX98XtmN1FrUGr9xvh61BgCtro3k4ovz lZOTUHfIkT1Dtp07IJaoH52Vo52wYTei3vWjg3LMB1F2t1k/5oMenQxComEJ9ORprsUFXFKz9NQO ojzKB8kuK6ImWp7mlUnawgO+xJJGsM0eAYLmeZ0TO4YWuXP4wUnyGomWdp5N4y6uo8sEJrRNY3/a bcPiTuGDY8ybnLFH6hPGFsZYp/s6s3PjuOJDJ2pSU6ZkDKo4NNGN6zipKTw1Dso0m+w4MwmKD0Nz BNvTIjPGbN5LMRfniTYbC4JKOc2Np+0fCM2Flz0EU7hiZ2PHi91hTnTEGbqDAnO00AjLvifZZfpi aHDOcM2/RH0iR5PNi0ydG1PECF8eQ3i8TbVry9XKPKC6vaPLYW3c5rvlzcGiUs1tnbxWb49aFVTL B9Csp5wv7FjL58OKllYq58MztKy1fD78GINVyvmca/l8euniauV8GFabWj48UXmlcj7nWj4fXrq4 Sjmfcy2f0YBaoZzPuZbPh5curlLO51zL5zOWLi5fzudcy6eotdXL+Zxr+RBDr6Ocz7mWTxmNt3I+ YwK0QwGeFj/QtvDcDD5yHdgPRZ9oAsSgW2654udTZ8tdSUsom3cBlk68fSobDWNulQBxa9dT/rrD TuFT2RiQWoJUan2bpczHmspmcMqc6gEdU/5sdwodoLlleRFGaKlYoSjiox6hJdC1AuG7zoWrcp+w /DSHbrkFuhz6NDPZ0F7r9zyInVd4sNnKAUfQ/cu5c36J4nhQpJhUVtngMxhQaHwrh7fA4J43TYOz T+dxLbvzml9iFxeAZXeeI83WIZVjlG6UW9kdfX4JWXQC2tikmCzlpSCGpi0Uo0nwOupxU5NZgSLM PpdCTDr51eMWrsEU6rpXfqO74T4ZtkWvFgldda6o9BRog2FLzilAbIioEAJtxlgjNIIjxohKDRKm YkoZWaFGjqzq8PI4qnq07NzNxvBSU/i68FTw4lBTaDDI7OpvYEYXFuMi18gJxCIcs5ntlnlfc8q8 v7zWItIuc+hTagrdMu/pawptk9J9eEW+h5pCU9TTjSPkJAsyNJcKH9qOyZ50m7wF73mY7scYeIFG 3vtYhmgu9T8eiZZYBZoxXiwflmlIopJLsFzKd6jM3Lo5VGxTtKQve7rSPQe5QQCA5sbNH0TrnHWV 1R91O3/QLueWwh+cH7sUn+h2tQ4A35NGMHa8wzAAOJIYm3NcTC6uNt0ksriV7BFmCTdu65aNFQdH jVj2Z7tuTVLAlSLUgQhiVN2tYM+i7wj2DBxS0jQka5aq0QFzKiEIlkVzpe6L9DG3o7oPq/QyWpgE hgbK1FOAI4Sbgy61ei4CiFyWZUlOWtpO+2wQ176+5jUp4Eoq6nVrl+KEcdpnw1ssyKGCzbgLBPjA 4ntS8oF7jZ6hTz7tkFPbbnmK3jj0CSVZrIernKI3Pu3EMbpueYvemN0oY9z4cG6O3sCyqFWiNxin fZ+uHL1JbOWDW3aenkHYUHoVp96jN+S4wPfpytEbMLhk0CFlhL4ejjJ643M6BwrVw60avYHFcAks CLlsXtIpRfRGWTeutYLk6A1VdZBm2UACeSoQcky8iJsMaZ9a6eVSGktlSJ8Rcy58Xiok81cuE0n0 HKwZXYnjuwxFMSvFsWdnepYuMYOYanAhWi5F8TR7Rj2jTIZwK2ODyRDGWOeSJX7uElf2PV1K/Ggq Wh1XsFyI6RCno0k7wQhECpuaGJq0kk3pgEBg7po3ZMEzMkfgiWPuWxdLV+aZvDW1OG/dlXnOaddr q8xz5bT1VObJ0UFLcZ53QM6VeR6SYVepzMNtaKw4b92VeVankDYx0lNlnlOqlWqErqEyz4df6GSz HtdUmadk3puL89ZdmUeYm3VX5rl4a6R9oVp7uo7Cf6jyXPLXqVMvASiW0uqkSL0E0Lh1SAFA8xuK TS9b0wBPuLxbh42BoFjykJfYLEaAjC62a3dsYzYI0MpHACAoymLEtSe2y+MpxZp4wLFt5j1VijWw 0o/2zOux8lxypqGSO0ixHjsrHXarxTrfd93OeKFPhd79Ma8gCplGTIXe/aEucHUw1Ut22RKe2a29 pqOOESC3s3BoXFwEyON6tFdr7bWsxzZROeIxG0rDH0HreToYMmyK2ZhSJsAILQlL8JlntxtHY6yD uiaez0xLw/u1Fsner7VI9n5NRbLPP2sokmU3ouspkgWA1lMkCwGtXiQLoaylSBaW0bkfdG3OHSSW kYGF4nAULFX+kjGdB8oK63rsiiuHwRRhg9XlrZwrZFeUZ1BrNLlCxmHSevfY3BAd/DUU5WHLU6nL +yNFecv7np6K8sjB+7UW5SlJFi7lmisX5fnQybCvzrqF0oPrSUQZJRu3mFygq74y5ly4n37v026P s5lk88HJSx8JpxDtx3YLyXPgGXZsbmv3LWPZdMxHKLvvTPiIpfKwnI5iD8jp5GEo2ONIB/pItbju VdemPpnOMzeyBZ527ZzuqlvzRXQGiQ1C/EL54PVWJhAZft7A2+RhZTG8eL0b2DvbZwOR8vU9vHj9 Bl68fhvYuy2k4W8t2LQUiJ51U0z84SujKKfD6RfeaTU+ZbxCT64Iw31PQ9ldK87glDYUwEm7W1P8 illj2V2wt3X9RSz2S4aencruXqNErOgmcgLW9CaqzfKRi/1encruAikyVngTuYY1YXNPIbkA7iDw 4nCt3NXJNYbVdIUevJ3bRyz2Sw33Tu73ZqRStI5T2d0HY8LqM95T+FInF/ttf8XbPRJW3gFrjckb rU5zbePH6SYRa+B5M31HonDEsdhvo9rYMU0tXLdRhB/9phYFLgZU7S43BVMGManpxuVhgAKkuOh+ 4aeNw1HrJqoeT1MXMfg8EjTpWKeYs3t+r9W4be18m/PzzXHYpYqLfPKdXjNinMo+wEK+0+vE9ixq ckYXubjI9Yoa6/6ZbXRwtev1jH1amBP813W9nt300YbtWrsbqxRnYgHip7L7bSuG3EGHu93M1+pR hO083KxHHKHP/S48t4tWaEboszsNbumqWKo7VmgJ73L9hId1w7w3k89UpMLjpORb+XSncG2FfXbe h9eYDUVhn52XYB+2W6mwz66qj2hDL1/YZxdFVALE6yzss6vqQ+tmvYV9duyj7a2tr7CPHO5ea2Gf XXoKJqHXVdjnmgm5nsI+u30ewi7uKoV9xnmVq/ocNlaWLewj7OKuu7DPoWJlnYV9tGd0rVjYh+X7 a1V99turKxX22SknOQK11sI+uz7hW99rKuyzq+ozZXSto7DPbg61dbO+wj47UOpm8RoL++yq+uwq VlYs7FuaaN4K+9yItqbCPruqPq9Eoyjss6vq8xEqvVYo7LOzSX3mqu/VC/vsZA+mpNdV2Ge32SL7 nmst7DMC2HF1cZcs7LOba/LGytKFffgsqTszTvpmycI+gu9JpMiShX0YOTQb00cuKFu2sM9uSD7s 5CSSvQq7taKPKOcL5CVL+VCw7Gp3OBWqqZ34bCAfEXejlq++cpUbJpNjHbf4uZkca7rF78jmCj9b k4OOVK53AGOsKgchyZfluZbq0/EBZAHB7c7ePbrpG5LVr32Cv9OVe2539dr2yZoyArtFs7Cp+qR6 obTCxoFUaQ/ChugyJbZyX3Gjy3RqdpmsiU3mmBnB9zTd/7dk8ZweZibm2VDa65SX/6mc5jwFK1/+ J0c53O7/o6zpW8cR4Std/ofZaQ73/9GXShEu//MahFzy8j/7IKT5/j+P9VLWy/98lgPP7e7/WyKD BKgJ7Bp7tcaDmJTrUDy3vhqP2dl6ziRHc5O/Wrma6Mw5v0NPuHSt6bPLcPSa3Q0nfuVbgs6ImcaW BBjXa/vImSHU5XHoxj6XBDq6JDVInQwdQxPvGzPsn4SCVncaFgUaNJ/BW/O0YQSj+tT1ZU4p8aCr SedYupdUK+QRrCfVCp1NsDqnAZrTZFnRFGKuYScFQTGYsnYsQAnIiw4kJ45BQEstRQsU4Oca143n SnscGvmQRJrL683Vvp9C0FLt+ym470bRF6B9ClT3I9vYfTZJ5ADaHpVgw5QZkZo3E0RNirnBnU2n zSlgxVlTttvycb7O+55UwcKSJR9lycKYu7Ve7ni3vssd70wlFMtKgfbUk3FPcKPQXXSr2Bg6FOf0 US+A1nCMgQxouRu+jf4NBOSQjeQtLRYsFJsSilU2i4FNZl2P4JlNCcUywfsl7v2zzUzBr/5bcj1i oNZ417fbvX+Upvqq9/6ppjrx6j+PpT+Ee/+8urhL3vtno9aMV/+tMi5LzMbbZX1maO73/pkCxI7V vkvd+0d9fHvt+Wfl+jLIAsDqczl5g77al92wdS01hvZW7ctueLtf3j6YAmkuUNR9uBZiqqX3ukew LCCq4JdLRhcCtFq1L4Iia8/Vq33vHc+2O0Ha00v1vSVrh+oWQYNlY66lsmbtwDKyO2eNZhsGs8uz AaN3WI8eC6ke0F4VWa3Z11I5Vcv1yNE+hdOoHXwAbUiRk2j27gnLE0D7olieFIVUD8jFX5Pv2RWd /XyL70lQUvlgzCFj0tViNIcfQLcca6m8Wow9eePWjAY8Xsfxc7BQboCdBG/cxV2i7rYUI6fy6ULB Zzrz3qEybZVTtaxEW9tlmD1J38ol7kbRWjalWIZCj/ooLxB86NJflErcjUL39K3tMkzQJ8dTRqjr bvVlfJQ6n9giVCahKYkiN4e1UUrB4GmuA0sNb+GPk0C4HzuFJYYlVGcYSzRzW9r07ZiIpvxmqJET JXZb1LEihjZeTbfB5XP2lXkHGzvEyjxx8RYj1wNCNAfch/kmvrB+NZ3NrYNatdqjUxXiJ2vyb0yF iO8XN0SsO+xpt0/COiDWyAE0UvaieIMN11gjJ20OBVJlXrZ+9LP1rY3VVJkXwuoBfdrtcRiRDzki VqaaYy4IWNObW9ff3KsdVoAGDteh/HGjKiXJWGuRtzYR664QzAyxQJe5JDDmhLW5S8QqSndHATus AI1ciHjyEr01TK2QU/Gj35TJCJUeB9807V4X3xODsCE0TW/+vFYeLl1BpoYK9ymKE5boPBdM5iiW ZBH8tkRgqguRrLM0zUeRnak47DY7Sk/ltVy7UIbOWNW06eWWjeRwK5/BHLa91o22W7QJn9a9MoMi AJNXdT5DiNYILpuCwD6bi2mo405PZdcbYLCES2dSeUncciuP2yM6YN7K40iZoD7TGQ== xFRc5TEHjJw1BEfomghPWwAIbHLndUNfAOiSLqfYaXTdIh/R43Xd7JPTaJXuWPNwjQ64zeGe8kVo 6/A0Ks7n7NJGbjuR+SqxMCPRKs9t5xQb2k3wynq2iTrRzTXE0yrrOIQS1iOqy9hHOtiMriSRNgiq hFSJJYkuR5DS1SPS1625eTUVxxwwuniaMRWFtW4O9bgf51FTCxu+ukZPupfYoJkMiip9fuMck1vW dB6PB3UBejkc/K8Gc3xy4T9dBOYrOzPfq2OOSRKMFJ98bI5rnR0w6Qg6gKqgDduQHNScTToPBW3Z hUmd+Fap9Oq5HMWgh9dk0UmusyMfxUBhqhsMKEuU1GtdIjaHpl1J2/MFqGtLXW/9scwhMWvoKyu6 lgpRc4RosQVWgkYsofVp9615geaZ8Z2I5lpN5Ilo6zofBUAj7oAuRTSHyjhLFbNxs3jJkkRasxGv v1miJNG4PMn1iD6b4z88lCQaO0GuR/SZ7pP2WJJIW4+oKgKij0SC4e2iQbu9NQ8liQSxZ6lHtHPY PZQkuqsaUvaDp5JEAkkt9YgmA8prSSKVe2jeXjUOyVPlkks9ItmTvryzH9dSlxXiUuAPXlaIu1GW 2sb1XVboFn5Y02WFuiJwlx8rXFZolml/6LJCJaS67MWAtJcVamG7P3tZIeI02K0/e1khnnn/By8r tA8/wG4JtteOIrta7o7bqVb4bYdaGtyqFx6qrGp/26HXbDvihYfLnGq1xIWHxMGt41Qr/cLDlXKg 6C88dC4A9K3hVCt04eEaTrWiufCQrt5z5QsPdQLZBT3sGHqpCw+PHG87xByP1S489FhQtuyFh2a2 MN52aEmAWfbCQ+fB+Rzv9/Rw4aHzbYcOsU5vFx46D0k21ddw4aFrMux6Ljx0vhRMkWmrX3jovIw1 U91cAuX1wkNnzWe205a+8NCQ/mS57dDWv1nmwkPnvCws7Xq1Cw8pSknWceGh822Hmr5Z9cJDj/cU LnvhoRGK+bZDa4B4yQsPyelqCpr1XHjovB+jyLTVLzx0rI6Rc9XXVa1Gvu0Q9whWuvDQeZ8H2QLr uPDQOcWbGLn1euEhqRgN34pYseQCQHMRIwYp4FJyIThdeOhBCqxy4aHGbra3HVpiNsteeOgMxUe8 p3D1kgvstsPVSknuiB66abeZLrWX4sJD5xxan3a+gLYel7vw0PnkEd3xWPHCQ63wy7Zi24cXLdGX QFkvPKSQaeu48ND5tsPVTXXlwsM1lGPTXHhI4+Ku4cJDFYq9x21Ra14vPHS9otBB2Cxx4aFTocfz j+J7rn7hoS2TabcdribT7mmNH3zfc6ULD52NHyz7YbULD3WC25UGe40OEi889F6Lu9SFh7ZQNFHs XLHi4cLD5TO6bC48XLZU36dUSK584aFhPVpuO5TRrOHCQ7Wqzv62Q0WmrX7hoXMSlWzcruHCQ2fv XiXa2gqv7G879BDrNBLNfOHh8r6npwsPSfJQvu1wXSmKJefbDn2mo/WXvvDQ+bZDxeRY/cJD5yJd eyW9xIWHzrcdutlp9EW6jrcd4kHIlS48XMayWeLCQ+Jsog0g49a3EzSXCw+p8jpXv/DQWVegkKpZ XQhzq+0GnpF1haImLGkkWjhYtWyY97t83BwRBs8c5L1zvr+xiFIuJcG4amYKeYEJapV0AWDYpw1P cCKg+gStDovfmJQUkgJQpuSkrlASxaPr0Ul8fnBaYLP3N9zu0UYZNYFVXfXwbYsXA9vP4Z0AjBoF dl/rw0Ds8LMQ3j/6yYUP9q874dvR15SpVD7jTOUzmmeqZ1cFqAiq01GTqV3lokyzcdFlmt/vH8zl WBgyN+eJHHPbGLWZO2n4zrSZ+Zhpvx4umPtoO8g8Ru5CzEtv45J5fX14Z7rXiTnzlnjYZd7Og1ei KFbiovQ83RcX7KQN0IiLbjYo7WZ2oJ1wPYfVprvR0aB+Wb/IvZ+0Xx4/Ans72w+trez+uLjduqmd 7gy/tjc2cvGL4Oa4v91I5nYue58P5YM9tSgxsIjMkhdvaFpQCRxAEyhUb2+3mS1hAB63prbiRJkb VPIqSbDAtRmIFjtJ7IJM5YbFfNFEL0QsSLTaVT4JKLL4Yd4OXkOieBEN68O1jDUZeggfJHZPmGrx rMhU3/unTO3y4lvafE33YDFtQEF49FMJH2Yvnph4tRvwyRWSV0ylnemi+w+Z+KUQMRlhxmVkuMrw LfitR2mxwenaSLcF5PrfnUDo4CIZiMZ327AMuBzYKmfjgUjo5AQ+Ow2ErzYuYC3wBXxxHIgWEoNA 5PyhHtj72QRj5X+yCmvL94tyYShEt9i9ErsP0JRGfJyFQ+ue7DcDIpqgaoU7z4LfbmZs5OPjCPzW /kHuPxP/2oihzxNbue85wwRjcfQnlJBB5bdPYQ98UQ/JCN93f8LyuqmHlSf5YBT+GVX+bCYVGEAe zCv9r58cE081mML3tCkVzu7vX5h6r/FQ7YaeztgIM3lT+3m2Fy5HthfVYL3RYCOl7R5Ao72L4O/u 2IH2Ioa/+DhUER41MYTAeZoVFcLU8iEwaZshZhAM5tEzNDe1k7DW/pWtvOYP1PbVqP4CZdmDZ824 bDvFa5cMDB+H4UZ+EnTnQp4Wtve6zatdvAqjqxyhTOvNWEiqq6jGS1tAxAShLXAVQ63YfrrEwT8Z lJDG9uuX6E8Fbv/xiVVmrlMNx89vvhLg7W0EveVC6fwAI9ptTEbDhLayDDe+2a5EcqHXk32mvYWL Pa38FDlZVtNXk8u3cR0eJNo6QDJYF9n4pnQQvtsX00d3yYtC5mUQVGyBIhd6vAkoU9t54rQZeUts HRy8IV7iQovBlzr0e4xfuHL9MAafxWQqlR8bLGJQrty/TKHfoJIuj+845fHi6RXpMa4S4rvKb9xH CsJIyTC6jycQ5GMMXbbFdcfA+EffdhfXCvC30MNQ7c4jh7oD0Mg9etsffGrvkuFK+6EOR9PDRvN2 HyjBdb6fOL6dXxfHsY+9Qqv/3iyfNQI3uhvJqPeQlrQwyQ5up+kxk2Jie9EQVKwvcTSQxA53l5QF wM7+U0r5rcyPtHYJpV37u2DqDkBTuCzdvlTL441+4fr2ebfSi57cAzuheYBO8FfWyHyWlgWQu0xV 715t/xg8ApPrjHTxUXq7tCg/VoWH8uZgUSm91K4f8i+X02Dlvnh+WgyNxRbQ4+l6scLEbvcfm5Oj 2rj98FyopwM9JApVoNtj2JNdhWhAjhayu0hCKCwLFZw8kIcvWdQi10IWnaON1o4mOiVV2MVkjwS5 jODPZAhtMQG3+2SKhE0qH2aB+QEFcT2izf4z+KjNwGcx5FVBmRJDoSG29hqDSTn1OGHDrM7YswB8 dxaEub8/ZlGLxAmUspiIlZ/dsZC1zwCDZNr10ttXYcAVH++OFXkIBCuT6p3BmTiDohMTv7XiTxrw yMclFIQAQ2caQ4SUq99l/VgrReRn/EZjBv5syE0gvT6L441Jla1HqywEwOqQoeisH19DUXe1Zwp8 y/6Frm2PDme6JQwzaap13eCzWHvHH5n8S+s8B9giDXPVwb8HxeLbxeYFepLfmZbz5U0h0gBcJVyf vN+yO+Atd1PNbaaOqrmt60Hp5XSzvr/4AAZ/LCm2geW8VzOyVlA9+CC+BQ85iMnB+51v1bh8A6o5 vbV1kq/8POcTpXK3cFt6fa7UWyP25KcQL5Qb3yMJLDK2qJgQyfJINe+kC+WQBcwgUbD69BuYFcRW rJtSJTx6HBZu2/fivpATvwo3i8Aw81O/blZ4fjdWeRxsDJHZBNBkF/IF6dvTlxI0MOKGw+idx2xF fc+VY7GD+2p3/sKe7J9+XTsPWI5D62PObYSPFjsBk6MIeWkXKh2gclOn38p5FNVuWF/xiWI2kU1v 5pvXgODCqPgVDF7pqAEaV3ID1Mf7RztLot4/2yrDXPVyrXb4VbgtJ348E57jih22QUH1dXLafDeW rBd3jX7rjhqBAjbJYZiJH3YUnqs8V380YxjpjJPSqLojnrR3H35OpnWxU+1G6puFy4+DJiBCcqv8 fiVdo0UpBV52y8xge1IGyzN/pc+1NS7giea0BAdoMJrvfUjbyPeBxsKx3eiXHDrSnpSjX4HdABpP o7cbeqIgBspaIECOrFn31ohi1SRTDw6i84Pygq81gUy9aQIlfXxWqKcCIpCk5Ztihauf5CrZfqQi vuZfccWdemKgcRuXZkM0SEM0YLVlb2J82Sm0LvuVJM6sVCp+7U6ey7HMroQmAbIA5bJfRc5BormP eWU5JzuFbmMmDhiw22wLLSjZvLvr7lXsUMvB+3XNtBwhmUSzY9OaQ2ptRSlPseYgmlWlPIVa98Bp umb3jhrNzR8wZWjU2kqmjC2tla1vd3J7GbCV3WR9QzXwVUYNw3Y2S2xFTrNYcQDN0iIGOYX8T8wp lDhPB0IXjzk4mnA/hs7MKwYiXPVC/jO0V+QC0efKDQylNWF47Qy8iIowgHYjx9hAk0ggmo2+BkKj 8VEgOrl6ht8ysPGxfOie5k0gTlPCbLvyCWXKaWTnE+jTRbHoBSOVJ8XL1gnwh1Opt8Lt/mew3HhK n4IZCW6cHBxXY5rz+qNPQny4PYHl2DDfJmceOD3qtnDSPjtsgHm4DVTe0pdDO/MKJSeZbIzDx81l sXL97t7J/vOwW45dv4ml98NJj9aygVhNloVnowrFOlcwKSmlO5ICdPqc2qiyIbi89b00zWlHvaJa 82RAETTravgNVIfG7VqMCmfUsMbDsxvhXdiu12EP7L2OZ5rzFtRJv7wb5Ynnkb4xd2FJLecQK7Bz 2Ln5Dr7i0K6JgfAwZtTBjy4zZsqhzyLlaw4qEaBYHoMnSN+Mk9VApDs4hU+YQORndi9v04SvNvah RrkMhN7es4FI+7UC2yXk813/lL5ZVhQA2Sub6uv3aSn1zaqoK/xb5etk8hN/A/iv4RF6HrTtNPLf q2+8qjrZFnAbs+OAgbBpb5WdAzdq9sMaAzdQxLdMqk7ltBUU/VX5fWe2CY3rHiBCv2s3dHUj3864 WsmyMi4yyAJe1tmSnK5kQi4fNqNDjSwbD+tsyUWmpMGtU7A4ybRVTEqKAeOcRrPOlhw13Cn0ss6W HDrOaTTrjHKRyVt4ehCBsIVXKsYYrnJf7FwUIjPmpNC/uqiWj8Op00Jkmt8tP1bnL4V6+u3i5P12 tl8RX3qX+8dsO4v2+8rHe5VE9fY409GDhdAcNMYLVwkWEq09gGbdgXo7Qw960muOaFAHUzxuzhiW QOHbTuL+eU8aWdiKt7bOiIbd0PF0nj/g5KhOFkCzZPhyxcjt0lsGVlt7iXjaUqE8DTXM5fizs4+7 uC6exh+N3BJdPGM8jV0hnhbceorB2Nkl/LPlyZexW+6qkjaveHZXmJeGmReBcrH/hJV0xNQwPE/e L2DOSV5JDMCzVGlX3PH13nPh9u7zlUrOod+03MF8RXZskcqTk1Y9Kv9Ctfs13qsWxg== /CedG4V+A4DCVSlwLLSV1Ao1cuqV53aDpVHgKeQaTNE5XeY0+Ft0b6exL2doFR/4OYWFLaf2/snZ Vzck//Dso6nXgvd/bPbR1AM0f3j2PWwTrTL7aOp9arHfH5t9LzuFK8w+mnpZ2PzJ2UcTjgLEf3T2 6Yxbx9mXDX9joM2anIVLaDl1XCFa0DCG2BRnKFT/o86vnDSLJ5Ja6uuwAzNM16vIKeknmOLeSU2r GC70bKNU2ND2qtqGW4pkACEdANSeO5FRxQQjXNo6rugGKhfMdRL6GNCzjY2j45rqxE738PHDid+o Vrd1ACjPZiMVN8F4eGgVNBijoCGRErAgWApBObOv8rwfhWmeLPDMyhGYVChXMqJnMPkwhp5BA+pF 6sJsu2dJTR3vzs0eFBohvPhJu9/oReeN8H7/8hxm0m+YLj6SyzWUrCG0iPdO7vd47AokbXWHgsdP L6CryRp4wRr5OzxR52YR0HP7A0npaUddnqEH+GJT3WEP74/vLnCG6kQmCtGKobOwenNP/SW28XmH 1pd87RXM/9S6M9ZJL1/UKhOhLN3IwRSZDs84HRZPlxodHox0CGtTO9x7EhM9lQh5FiNC6XHwqhIh FjVn22VEVzrsbSE6yN05Lv3gq0o+8xQSQcGqXF8E0MjT4k6HxFbuKy5jTWQuvxQicAuWghmU0FBc Z/GHwDRekekgFjtPOh2Cva3rZwIzhIIYIbcPAm8mblI5zRFGyBmGO4A9NaS6AgycI0jLAqBxWhmh yKqdiBqX51IwYhQDQaPwoepVWxjxVQfCGETncqzFeuJN6BFYYERC3te5EcCeCYBsQ3uDsQZhE4kQ YNDOSCRqB0AmmoEz8H6YYcQoZiRxchUMKgD440tzEDKyKmtFGCIA1cV1h8FSUJO40mXLJsKpMNKb +jqTNmpnJQOu+J7ebmuS2G+p1/B9c8Z2Zi4hcJrTuOJLCCAzp8VtGcUDu8dtuQQ57NRrP74sl2Cc FmdWHQhZAFFzWpxbpRMyp8UT7suunjw8L4VlGOJRKmHoBOcigFR940QMLrJqJ6JGJb3MjHAxCrYA aJxmhKMxeeyEmAaAWV1Jc6zxT6Mo4BK6BycnJ51ITDx1GDHkeYc3UWL3/mOzmyv0r2bbij+aOlGr Jh+YTWRXmjxTNvyVgVeFdl7V+iPEAlphX1cri3oDXusYVQlFlHLCVEdUaiDnwRjyTZQCrVRsV/2N DaLKOECTDHAVUpk95LSgqiNkdYKBoCfA7XkCNnSqFFO/rMZVn6fO4LWlu8NvtbY0E9JrS1HdrVob dagXkcqWzVbpUH1X0utIXwwFVQ0N4RmOMLrV0OoHL+TiW7bW3NDKSi/ChppC6Lr1tXdRvCxrlofc chFXC9ouGLnUtJ5uJqAbE00c3wUWTLx1sqfTXylea1URnfbktAShiGx+GFbIwrhLFnx+CcjXuozD yE4EnR8B/rxj0UdyZVy89ZTQKlWBFNg82IRvwwBDDHjmnaZOmDcMDYpPPEbLcf5gJ/8x2b2rHlSS nyYnEp4McYWfyKQey6TufTRzas0/Dg+gWQWkIYQSOs1e5bK16smucFtuDA4DyhLoPMDyOHVqbzms IDU07m6qxax8Uhs9D9DMcwpb9C6jiOcVDu7dxRWe7z0wbK/ZCIHfnljtsMZ475U7yjU4MGU9PqH+ NkgiGMr8fl0jkFF0CgX480Gt0Px6YtTfXlmtOz1u97h5pHTna5DAl2ePew0kukql6vnPtjKar+80 tokkvIbeS8N09bI4zm5msQSro+pijA6PkIek/1BGo59KB5b4Q0zD2ldYZv7KsDX2JAh+41n1t4Fe Fdzndg+vwQjnn0lLd1LzdnUvdARL5TPt6MZ59e18OyfXCu50pQxzWgvDQt+XtCKAZPl1PjGVi9LW iqLdqOXLRWlrRWGK4grlorS1oj5DRb7nclHaWlHVHFyyXNSuVvT/Ajsmk8yx/kwG/IhfL8aCeCmO PkYTf8T3F+CGeKHBsneTwbQqCsKt8M+8PO0vvoXJ3J/3xws3pUYjmyoL/elAgB/AuX7LaJIjqnRX 4XD8TBVDbiEK+RbL77naV33z+pAvvzOdI3Pm4e7s9geel1FXNuW2YTLhE9yUuwkE61IE/tmRgz1y PNV0OI0cAUWyaW+zLIjFRSV83rw3FY4j2yP3dls7hIkGqLo1Ln0coLKt8mP5eLh/zGZjxdD3zk3p pTEuV57ewjwSRtZzYZo50oCVIe29VKGigqN6UPIjz+8fAsEovwG3Dk/hj3140kUrEI3vmHYXc3Cs 2yYpzQjzkywyLPTTGYz6kN/6fpYF1O5hJ6UWbncRP0VVS+JZgn9qmrG+q/0WlKWUIH2h0y/2lMMt 2I0IWolaPsN7KRaT16H6ZVxfpfjBE0fJIHYEhnb6BHiR38PMCezoiaOTCC5zX3B5fFSNYS9eFq8n +oKjPfhCP/UColn64Auo4mt3HNL4uAZrATMcGgWKBms1orpjBE9WkpdMqxmTTYfdwwcgJVvXDPci 9VjwYwD/fJDhgnUzkQ8q4UJbsZB6BEYDzWYYt8E6lzEVjTctZD5mVVdBneu4HTyYnbE0yDsG24K6 O8yXCnc7+2+lYeZsVrgtTO5lO6P4tPeKUsHQ+Rb9B+1YhtuEbh/jk9xrRjBzQtaWvWvZeob31Ybk 3/iNtmxdAKrfINMYRf2Lj4k6yo0GDHXQQL8p89v7SMmmg6wAv+5i0HBkNQUYBcALQfk3zOj94jnM ZIBqwaedUPP1kVSNo8cUdgSGUrHvyfyDp2fKPxRbDUtybx7gTDl/isNeQp4r7Mm/VZ5Pw/JvWM/n Hwn0jCt2whVTd9KP3/Vx+X1bgo7RycHxQ1I1E16A6VC7CirHaIy2d5CKNwrMEn5sFqAmfnqQdraP t9ODDjQheiwfIRT5mV3anx6knU+k7NDGd5QNIvWWLmDqKEv8UtiTV5zGI4i/4dEeUbhkGflkkOP7 Co8YFJ4ZFFNEJ3AvoOiMGEVnnCtHn8Kq/6W5WVF08BhywuBJZw+KcK6dhZRj94BPZn/0aqrBWFgA vQDCVra8OjGTqEXDBXJu8KScQNQMw2DTWVQxZz4O4+XTgyljErFwm2MsWxxGx0zdzJbPFwMOWgwN EslWOMnnkAUzijEHZKpsv8j2KRSninF0IVMT+mQ6cP0wIS0WS3N+isxLlgNMOXzidRZEjvxh/BMP KNTt9hm3kxflK3WfUQyb9ipF8eD4Ro9qMI3nSMwIYKjUwCSv53LylHRns626ie/LPnKnpj1VpnJw WdH2Za+sABabpn3Z+k4dX2LAdkdmg2K2Ry44eN44ZMF6GP4W057FtWdgbiI30J8IirLNDqz3R2su /fKhGLRDLZ9h9oIdVXaw/32tbWd25FwTdSfPvJ0JV9wq25no0HWVaJ538iAdzLsUzoE1Oepviq0l fzQ6vOJ0QLvMCh0ecSKA7uBEAL6LiQgqQ+N04A8udDoknsZsFsssAMZHzPvetpbSAuhAs0HhxAwn C+KerpLeim1v2zNDraUz1DOJocgA5MyZm8kqMNChsc4A5Pw5ZxidGcXKcAKgHmG+ykC6IgUA5+UJ j/dcbSDoME9FdC47kCGZtWjTJmrjAC0MgqBq63z1qhDN6zpvdaaeBAUcjQXG82w1YdPqmqWVRjTq GWn1RPtO4AAeTQAU41aDIUgrJYEctYZzO/6Go6EfyNdiyUXmUy9nOWpNA+7EcFojLVFN2Up2vnUA TP280zcRrfOscVAH6y9TfakbztDtdCm45MHEaeZMo97PagKoI5i5ROc0Wm7tDN25xNIJM9G+bBnF w0AmCztqIk6jHoi4rADSOa2z2Fht7T9ublIoaU561mEEdtvDG0NGY28lAYSUdE/4cSOGSyeGBAGk dkLRN07E6H1Jq7FFbzLXlfSSQqz3QyOA7JX0TPFaofn4ng/m8MhlLp6BAdesfoIx8vRg3E85hFb2 Kw47ST0GJG+Y4ifz/pFjeWXHAz+ZN7zSsbx6mMSwxYmSQAi7nLRbnLgnvf9RUF9c6ttNr3KiAQwv 1Q71iOgrjrpWimAvMNRwY2CwE9kDHv9zWHaxX6RPwBG1a7QVGdK3OA27zKZdzjVucSoFCLa7nGvc 4vShqzTtdznXuMUJ0BB3Ode4xYkynAm7nGvc4jTuZBp3Ode4xYmkAGGXc41bnHbhbnWXc41bnD7t TuX1nohr2uKEaP7EibimLU4o0wi7nDM1zeMECYWgQmkgxLSdTMOh47MSo0YMcXGGttqwnczDPXWQ F2E8YviKojIXSvyxNsvHlWQNZTtVULZCgCTTgeviTL0nQYI7nHBXG+5jdiuTAb6HCR5vg0c3wnwx Q01S3aLwMZo0+d+C6PuL9cv/MeA/+C+XSvkzOfg/xp+CD5s931/Bwnjs/xj/ng2lkL8Jk3W68YI4 L4/689F0wou//Xn07OG8edco+/N++EFX/WAf/NlgmS74ArwNoT3ULuxu1/cX4y/AHw9/+/5awF+A ocbEMimGAz2KpTO5dDaBfmE4jgO/5Bg2nUR9Bd/w8ANW/es3/OsU/PYJnv3tZxn/uf/phfEPfODl te+vdDYVy+QS/mwuEcukmYT/GzzLJGLJdDoLHmZjXIrL+dPpXCzFZRL+HMPFmCSHPWCZGJtKJfzA ncAepmIMlwLfAUhcjgUPAMQEoGE6k4zlkomkP8dxMfgAfpZJxdJcNgeepWNMKgWgZ7KxXCrBolZJ NpkGTwBo0B1/LsHEsmk26y/BD7WHyRjHZSH4TCyTSQHwCdCDdDLn78Bm2Vg6B7uVZEDn0zkEjUll 0+BJIpbNMjn/LwUaAzqdS4L2qUwGNEuD3mcB/DTrT6dyMTbHJtEfsNdJQIms/Gc6kY1lMynsy0Qu luAAnTQE8AvwEJA7hfUD/JJmMqbuAmBwRvRBaQ+UobdlWEkOYNIpBPqTAbTTiZiENIe9wkidBHhy AIQ+IaDL2VQihc2Z/gSbWu2hygBJMJFsGmORBCdPhsZJ8DOOAWMAvctmc6BZMulPs5xMxmw2GUun mTT+hJXZB36oPQSTl8jhrTIsopI6HfDvpu+vDJMm/S0D0B+oaH7hrbTegPGwqSyH9di8QkD33n1/ 3fn+yvmDIf/Dve+vZlERIUCiIAEShbsT2y3+Q7gV+dEYSpQPif8l+PnJZDrn58IMvPJ/iII0n4qC XxpO/4ZP4EfaB0A+XVZ9f/0/y9aJNA== Fermin D. Adriano
  • 2639

Rice Tarrification:  Good or Bad for the Country?

 



How should government manage its rice imports? Can we ever be rice sufficient? Resurgent contributor Fermin D. Adriano explains the economics of this enduring but controversial "political crop."


A milestone reform agenda in Philippine agriculture introduced by the Duterte administration is the lifting of the “quantitative restriction” (QR) on imported rice to be replaced by tariff (import tax) by end of June this year.   The policy shift means that any importer who can pay the appropriate tax to be imposed by the government on imported rice can bring in rice to the country.  Under a QR regime, rice importation is only allowed by the government on the basis of its calculation of how much rice the country needs to import on an annual basis.

Part of the agricultural liberalization accord when we joined the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 1994 was that all agricultural commodities under QRs shall be replaced by tariffs by country-signatories.  However, the Philippines, Japan, South Korea and Israel bargained that it should keep its QRs on rice for some time because of its importance as a political commodity.  WTO acceded but the exemption made was time-bound.  The three other countries (i.e., Japan, South Korea and Israel) already lifted their QRs on rice in favor of tariffs, leaving the Philippines the only country remaining under the old QR regime.  The Duterte administration decided that it is time for the QR to go by middle of this year.

Why the need for QR?

Those who favor the maintenance of a QR regime on rice cite three major reasons for its necessity.  One, during the debate on whether we would ascend to the WTO or not in 1994, pro-QR “intellectuals” noted that our rice farmers could not compete with their foreign counterparts because of the subsidies given to the latter by their respective government to make them efficient rice producers.  Note that 25 years after we joined WTO, the pro-QR “intellectuals” still peddle the same argument!

Two, there is thin supply of tradeable rice in the global market (which is around 7 percent, USDA 2016).  The country cannot be left to the mercy of the whims of the global market and hence, the necessity of being “rice self-sufficient” because of the strategic importance of rice to the Filipino consumers, particularly the poor.  QR is a key policy instrument in our drive to become self-sufficient.  Again, despite the extension of QR for 25 years and that almost a quarter of the Department of Agriculture’s (DA) budget went to rice productivity enhancement programs, we remain a net rice importer averaging 10% of our rice consumption requirement throughout these years.  In fact, an article by Briones and Olivar (2015)shows that for the last hundred years, we only experienced being a rice surplus producer for 9 years!

And three, we need to protect our rice farmers from low-priced imported rice.  Our rice farmers will have a hard time competing with the low-priced imported rice which means that they have to abandon rice farming altogether in favor of higher value crops to be able to economically survive.  Poor as they are, they will become poorer.  Because they are poor, pro-QR “intellectuals” further argue that rice farmers and their family are also rice consumers when their rice stock is depleted even before the onset of the next harvest season.  Thus, the need to maintain a protective wall against the entry of rice imports to enable them to survive!

Flawed logic

But the arguments of the pro-QR “intellectuals” are founded on flawed logic.  First, if we could not become efficient (competitive) rice producers after 25 years and after spending nearly three-fourths of the DA’s budget [1] on rice productivity enhancement programs throughout those years, there is no assurance that we will ever be able to be competitive rice producers in the future.   The reason has nothing to do with the efficiency of our rice producers or the budget that we put into it; the simple reason is that the country is not naturally endowed [2] to become competitive rice producers.  Unlike Vietnam, Thailand and Myanmar which have vast tracts of contiguous land irrigated by the expansive Mekong river, the Philippines is an archipelagic country whose islands are mostly mountainous and sloping.  It will take more resources to irrigate its lands given the relative difficulty of accessing fresh water sources.   We simply do not have, as economists term it, a “comparative advantage” in rice production.

Second, the country is not entirely relying on the thin supply of tradeable rice at the global market with the shift from QR to tariff [3].  What tarrification is doing is just to make rice trading a more transparent process instead of being held at the whims of government officials.   Stories of corruption abound on rice purchase of the NFA, the purchase of rice on a government-to-government basis, and the allocation of the minimum access volume (MAV or in-quota) of rice to favored groups and cooperatives.   All of these are due to the opaque manner by which rice trading is conducted under the QR regime.  So much leeway is given to government officials to decide on how much to import, at what price, when to import and where to distribute imported rice.  As we all know, many government officials are neither angels nor saints who can resist tempting offers from vested interest groups.  

If the shift to tariff is made, there is no need for under-the-table deals with NFA or other concerned government officials because any importer who can pay the taxes on imported rice can bring the goods in.   Also, government will benefit from increased revenues from taxes collected from imported rice. 

But what about the argument that tarrification will result in higher rice smuggling?  Theoretically, it would if the tariff is set so high.  This means that if the price of imported rice plus the tariff imposed is higher than the local price, there will be an incentive to smuggle rice to avoid paying taxes.  But the argument gains greater traction under a QR regime because if the cost of imported rice is much cheaper than the local price, then windfall profits can be realized in rice smuggling.  This is the primary reason why rice smuggling flourished during the Aquino administration wherein the US Department of Agriculture FAS Manila estimated, based on industry sources, that smuggled rice to the Philippines amounted to 400,000-600,000 metric tons per year from market years 2012/13-2015/16.   

And three, the argument that QR is needed to protect the welfare of poor rice farmers and consumers is inherently flawed using simple arithmetic.   Our population is around 100 million, most of whom eat rice as a staple food.  Assuming that, we have 10 million rice farmers and their dependents relying on rice farming for their income [4].  Due to the entry of cheap imported rice, the tendency of rice prices is to go down.  Undoubtedly, this will have a net beneficial effect on the welfare of the 90 million rice consuming Filipinos.  On the other hand, cheap imported rice will adversely affect the income of 10 million rice farmers and their dependents because the former will reduce the selling price of their produce.  

In a situation wherein 30-40% of food expenditures of the poorest segment of the Filipinos goes to rice purchase, lower rice prices will mean savings for them, savings that they can either use to buy more nutritious food items or other basic needs of the family (i.e., clothing, shoes, etc.).  On the other hand, rice farmers will at face value, lose but will also be partly be benefited by lower rice prices by virtue of being rice buyers during the time when their rice stock is depleted.  

Win-win solution

The solution lies in providing social protection to affected farmers by cushioning the impact of rice tarrification.  Note that not all rice farmers will be equally adversely affected by tarrification given that the great majority of our rice tillers are competitive (efficient producers).  What will be crucial is to assist those who will lose out from the reform measure by encouraging them to shift to the production of high-value crops or providing them skills for other livelihood projects.  For the rest, government can help them by providing greater assistance that will improve their productivity such as irrigation, fertilizer, subsidized credit, improving farm to market roads, post-harvest facilities and more effective extension support services.  The funds for this social protection program can be sourced from the tax collected from imported rice.  

The government now has a farm registry that identifies who the active farmers are in the countryside.  There is still a lot of work to be done to make it a better system.  But it can be the start of a targeted social protection program for the rice farmers who will be negatively affected by tarrification.  

The DA should be moving towards this direction instead of nostalgically wishing for the extension of the Jurassic measure called QR on rice.  It should listen to agricultural economists who have advocated for more than thirty years for this reform measure rather than to ideologues.  It is about time that we become more scientific in our policy-making process on agriculture.  

1. To the detriment of other major agricultural commodities such as coconut, corn, sugar and cassava, which also need major funding support, particularly on R&D, to increase productivity.  The “poorest of the poor” Filipinos are in the coconut, corn and municipal fishery sectors.   

2. A good analogy is our passion for basketball, a game to which we will never excel at the international level no matter how much money we pour in to its development because we are not “genetically predisposed” to meet international success in the game. 

3. A previous mechanism proposed to cushion us from the so-called thin supply of tradeable rice at the global market was to forge an agreement with rice-surplus producing countries (i.e., Vietnam, Thailand and Myanmar) in the ASEAN to set aside a certain portion of their production as buffer stock for emergency purposes.  Rice deficit countries like the Philippines, Indonesia and Malaysia will have a priority access to this buffer stock when they need it provided that they pay a subscription premium to this stock during a certain period of time (i.e., right after harvest season) till they need it during their lean rice season.  If the subscription time elapsed without the rice-deficit countries securing stock or just partially securing the stock, the rice-surplus countries can sell the stock to the open market.  The arrangement offers a number of benefits to the country because: (a) it is guaranteed of supply during the lean months when it needed the grains most; (b) it will reduce government expenses because it does not need to ship and stock the grains in the Philippines but will only do so when it needed the supply; and (c) it will lessen corruption as it does away with government-to-government transactions which are so opaque that it encourages corruption among government officials involved in the negotiations.   Unfortunately, the proposal did not meet the approval of our previous government officials. 

4. Households of rice farmers do not solely rely on rice farming for their income.  They are engaged in variety of livelihood activities, such as poultry raising, vegetable gardening, piggery, tricycle driving, etc.  to augment their income derived from rice cultivation. 

(Fermin D. Adriano, PhD. serves as Professorial Lecturer at UP Los Banos’ College of Public Administration, teaching development studies at its doctorate program.  The author wishes to thank Dr. Rolando T. Dy and Mr. Senen Reyes for reviewing the paper.)

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE